5 crucial strategies for effective parenting
© 2016 Gwen Dewar, Ph.D., all rights reserved
Aggression in children can take many forms:
hitting, kicking, or biting; hot-headed outbursts that destroy property;
cool-headed bullying; verbal attacks; attempts to control others through
threats or violence.
What sets children off?
In some cases, kids lash out because they're frustrated by a
problem that's too big for them. They haven't yet learned how to control their
impulses, or work out conflicts in socially acceptable ways.
In other cases, kids may be wrestling with special
difficulties -- like stressful life events, emotional regulation problems,
attention deficits, autistic symptoms, or hyperactivity.
Yet in all cases -- even where children have been diagnosed
with serious conduct disorders -- adults can have a powerful influence.
Aggression doesn't happen because we're programmed to
respond to the world with hostility. We all have the capacity to behave
aggressively. Whether or not we do it depends on how we perceive the world.
tendencies are shaped by environmental conditions -- the pressures, threats,
opportunities, and consequences that children experience. By tweaking these
conditions, we can improve behavior and change the course of development.
That doesn't mean it's your fault if your child is acting
out. Genetic factors put some kids at higher
risk for trouble. So do prenatal factors and early life stress. Stress
experienced during childhood can reprogram the way an individual's genes function, and even affect the next generation (Provençal et al
2013). A baby might be born with certain genes "switched off" because of stressors his parents encountered when they were growing up (Rodríguez and Feig 2013).
Aggression in children is also influenced by environmental forces outside the
home. Peers, teachers, neighborhoods, media messages, ideologies, and cultural
factors all play a role. And these environmental effects will vary depending on your child's
genes, prenatal factors, and early life exposure to stress.
Studies indicate that some kids don't experience a normal spike of the stress hormone cortisol in response to stressful situations. Others might experience a surge, but take an unusually long time to recover. Both types of children are at higher risk for developing aggressive behavior problems (Scrool et al 2017).
But whatever factors put
a child at risk, there is nothing inevitable about the outcome.
get the help they need, they can have an important impact. Randomized, controlled
studies show that aggressive kids change trajectory when parents get practical training
and moral support (Furlong et al 2013; Piquero et al 2009; Shellby and Shaw 2015; Waller et al 2013; Maaskant et al 2017; Scrool et al 2017).
The interventions work,
in part, because parents learn specific tactics for handling aggression. But
they also work because parents learn to change their outlook.
Struggling with a
child's behavior problems is stressful and demoralizing. It saps your
resilience, your sense of optimism, competence, and goodwill. It can redefine
the parent-child relationship in a destructive way, and prompt you to think about your child in ways that undermine your ability to cope. Counterproductive thoughts fuel the conflict and make behavior
Replace these toxic
mental habits with positive, constructive, problem-solving thoughts, and you can
stop bad behavior before it erupts (Dittman et al 2016; Furlong et al 2013; Shellby
and Shaw 2014).
So whether children are merely
going through the "terrible twos," or struggling with more difficult
problems, we should take heart: With the right tools, we can turn things around.
Here are evidence-based
tips for handling aggression in children, presented in two parts. The first part
concerns adjusting your outlook as a parent. The second part concerns practical tactics for teaching kids to master their negative
Tips for maintaining a confident, constructive outlook
1. Don't take it personally.
When your child fails to
comply with a request, it's easy to feel disrespected. It's easy to feel targeted
when your child flies into a rage. But these emotional reactions, however
natural, are wrong-headed.
First, kids don't
process emotions and information the way adults do (see below). If your child
is very young, there's a lot she doesn't understand about her own feelings, let
alone yours. If your child is older, it's still likely that your child's
misbehavior reflects impulsivity or incompetence-- not malice.
suggests that our pessimistic social beliefs -- the tendency to attribute
hostile intentions where none exist -- can become a self-fulfilling prophesy.
People who assume the worst tend to provoke negative behavior from others. And
parents who make hostile attributions can end up creating the very problems
they want to solve.
In one study, mothers
who made hostile attributions about their toddlers were more likely, three and
half years later, to have children with aggressive behavior problems.
This link between maternal beliefs and aggression in children remained significant even after the researchers controlled for pre-existing
child difficulties, as well as the negative parenting behavior that tends to go
accompany hostile attributions (Healy et al 2015).
Reminding yourself not to
take it personally isn't just good for your mood. It's good for your
relationship, and good for your child's long-term development.
2. Get realistic expectations about your child's ability to follow
rules and comply with requests.
Young children have
shorter attention spans, and they are easily distracted. They take more time to
process verbal instructions. Their working memory capacities -- the sheer
number of things they can keep in mind at any given moment -- are more limited.
Learning new information, and adapting to a change of rules or procedure, may
take longer than you realize (Lee et al 2015). Young children require more
practice than older kids do, and older kids need more practice than adults (Yim
et al 2013).
So when we issue
directions, we shouldn't expect young children to respond quickly and
efficiently. They work a slower speed, and it's harder for them to transition
from one activity to the next. They need us to provide them with clear, simple
directions, and then give them the extra time they need to switch gears.
Older children can
handle more complexity and speed, but their attention spans, working memory
capacities, impulse control, and task-switching skills are still developing.
tuning into your child's pace and abilities -- and providing patient, calm
reminders -- you reshape the task into one he's got the equipment to solve. And
your child will get to experience the social and emotional rewards for
cooperating -- a crucial experience for his long-term development. You invest
more time, but it's an investment that will pay off.
3. Get realistic expectations about the development of empathy and
kids are still learning about emotions -- how to regulate their own moods and
read the minds of others. Dependent, inexperienced, and vulnerable, young
children are more easily threatened, and thus more likely focus on protecting
their own interests (Li et al 2013). Older kids, too, may respond this way if
they perceive the world to be hostile or unjust.
And some kids are at a physiological
disadvantage. They have the ability to learn about social signals, but their
brains don't reward them as much for doing so (Davies et al 2011; Sepeta et al
2012). As a consequence, kids are less likely to learn on their own. They need
So while your child's
behavior might look selfish, that doesn't mean she's incorrigibly
Children demonstrate a capacity for empathy and kindness from a
very early age. When they fail to show concern for others, it's often because
they perceive the situation differently, or don't know how to control their
impulses. They need opportunities to learn -- by developing secure
relationships with us; talking about their feelings and the emotional signals
of others; and observing positive role models, and growing up in an environment
that rewards self-control and cooperation.
4. Focus on maintaining a positive relationship.
Researchers see families fall into a common trap:
When kids misbehave frequently,
parents tend to focus on all those daily conflicts. They feel obliged to answer
every offense with criticism or punishment, and end up with a relationship
that's mostly characterized by negative exchanges.
It's a grim outcome, and
it's also counter-productive. Studies suggest that kids are more likely to
learn desirable social skills when we provide them with positive feedback for
making good choices -- not threats and punishments for doing the wrong thing.
a diet of negativity can make kids become more defiant. Negative parenting can lead to a downward spiral of misbehavior, punishment,
retaliation, more punishment, and more misbehavior (Cavell et al 2013).
How do you stay calm and
upbeat? It isn't easy, not if your child seems stuck in "defiance mode."
You'll need social support, and maybe some professional guidance. Studies show that therapists specifically trained in handling aggression in children can help reduce stress and improve behavior.
One approach, used internationally, is the so called "Oregon Model" of Parent Management Training (Scrool et al 2016; Kjøbli et al 2016; Maaskant et al 2017; Thijssen et al 2017). Through weekly sessions of coaching and role playing, parents learn effect ways to set limits, foster cooperation, settle arguments in a constructive way, and inject daily life with pleasant, loving activities.
But the first
step is reorganizing your priorities (Cavell et al 2013). Maintaining positive relations is more
important than prosecuting every failure. Sometimes you need to choose your
battles. For more information, see my tips for handling aggression in children, as well as these positive parenting tips.
5. Don't sacrifice your own psychological well-being.
Dealing with aggression is very stressful, and stress hurts. It makes us ill, clouds our
thinking, and damages relationships. It's contagious -- even young infants pick
up on our negative moods (Waters et al 2014). And when parents are stressed out, it adds fuel to
the fire: Their children's behavior problems tend to get worse.
So addressing your own
well-being shouldn't be an after-thought, a luxury to be put off until your
child's behavior problems improve. It's a pressing issue, a central player in
the crisis. For help, see these tips for coping with parenting stress, and don't
hesitate to seek professional advice from a therapist trained to handle
aggressive behavior in children.
Your therapist or physician may recommend that you participate in an evidence-based parenting support group, like Triple P (the "Positive Parenting Program"). As noted above, such programs have a positive track record (Furlong et al 2013).
How to defuse defiance and aggression in children
For more information about handling disruptive behavior and aggression in children, see these evidence-based tips. In
addition, see these articles for promoting cooperation and self-regulation skills:
References: Aggression in children
Cavell TA, Harrist AW, and Del Vecchio T. 2013. Working with parents of aggressive children: Ten principles and the role of authoritative parenting. In RE Larzelere, AS Morris and AH Harrist (eds): Authoritative parenting: Synthesizing nurturance and discipline for optimal child development. American Psychological Association.
Dittman CK, Farruggia SP, Keown LJ, and Sanders MR. 2016. Dealing
with Disobedience: An Evaluation of a Brief Parenting Intervention for Young
Children Showing Noncompliant Behavior Problems. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 47(1):102-12.
Davies MS, Dapretto M, Sigman M, Sepeta L, and and Bookheimer SY. 2011. Neural bases of gaze and emotion processing in children with autism spectrum disorders.Brain Behav. 1(1):1-11.
Dodge KA, Malone PS, Lansford JE, Sorbring E, Skinner AT,
Tapanya S, Tirado LM, Zelli A, Alampay LP, Al-Hassan SM, Bacchini D, Bombi AS,
Bornstein MH, Chang L, Deater-Deckard K, Di Giunta L, Oburu P, and Pastorelli
C. 2015. Hostile attributional bias and aggressive behavior in global context. Proc
Natl Acad Sci U S A. 112(30):9310-5.
Furlong M, McGilloway S, Bywater T, Hutchings J, Smith SM,
Donnelly M. 2013. Cochrane review: behavioural and cognitive-behavioural
group-based parenting programmes for early-onset conduct problems in children
aged 3 to 12 years (Review). Evid Based Child Health. 8(2):318-692.
Healy SJ, Murray L, Cooper PJ, Hughes C, Halligan SL. 2015. A
longitudinal investigation of maternal influences on the development of child
hostile attributions and aggression. J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 44(1):80-92.
Kjøbli J, Zachrisson HD, Bjørnebekk G. 2016. Three Randomized
Effectiveness Trials - One Question: Can Callous-Unemotional Traits in Children
Be Altered? J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol. 30:1-8.
Lee HW, Lo YH, Li KH, Sung WS, Juan CH. 2015. The
relationship between the development of response inhibition and intelligence in
preschool children. Front Psychol. 6:802.
Li Y, Li H, Decety J, and Lee K. 2013. Experiencing a
natural disaster alters children’s altruistic giving. Psychological Science.
Maaskant AM, van Rooij FB, Overbeek GJ, Oort FJ, Arntz M,
Hermanns JMA. 2017. Effects of PMTO in Foster Families with Children with
Behavior Problems: A Randomized Controlled Trial. J Child Fam Stud.
Farrington DP, Welsh DC, Tremblay R and Jennings WG. 2009. Effects of Early
Family/Parent Training Programs on Antisocial Behavior and Delinquency. Journal of Experimental
Criminology. 5(2): 83-120
Matthew J. Suderman, Frank Vitaro, Moshe Szyf, Richard E. Tremblay. Childhood
Chronic Physical Aggression Associates with Adult Cytokine Levels in Plasma.
PLoS ONE, 2013; 8 (7): e69481
Rodríguez L and Feig LA. 2013. Chronic Social Instability
Induces Anxiety and Defective Social Interactions Across Generations.
Biological Psychiatry 73(1): 44–53
Romero E, Richards MH, Harrison PR, Garbarino J, Mozley M.
2015. The Role of Neighborhood in the Development of Aggression in Urban
African American Youth: A Multilevel Analysis. Am J Community Psychol. 2015
Schoorl J, van Rijn S, de Wied M, van Goozen SHM, Swaab H.
2017. Neurobiological stress responses predict aggression in boys with
oppositional defiant disorder/conduct disorder: a 1-year follow-up intervention
study. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 26(7):805-813
Sepeta L, Tsuchiya N, Davies MS, Sigman M, Bookheimer SY, and Dapretto M. 2012. Abnormal social reward processing in autism as indexed by pupillary responses to happy faces. J Neurodev Disord. 4(1):17. doi: 10.1186/1866-1955-4-17.
Shelleby EC and Shaw DS. 2014. Outcomes of Parenting
Interventions for Child Conduct Problems: A Review of Differential
Effectiveness. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 45(5):628-45.
Thijssen J, Vink G, Muris P, de Ruiter C. 2017. The
Effectiveness of Parent Management Training-Oregon Model in Clinically Referred
Children with Externalizing Behavior Problems in The Netherlands. Child
Psychiatry Hum Dev. 48(1):136-150.
Waller R, Gardner F, and Hyde LW. 2013. What are the
associations between parenting, callous–unemotional traits, and antisocial
behavior in youth? A systematic review of evidence. Clin Psychol Rev. 33(4):593-608.
Waters SF, West TV, Berry Mendes W. 2014. Stress Contagion: Physiological Covariation
Between Mothers and Infants. Psychol Sci. 25(4): 934–942.
Yeager DS, Miu AS, Powers J, and Dweck CS. 2013. Implicit
theories of personality and attributions of hostile intent: a meta-analysis, an
experiment, and a longitudinal intervention. Child Dev. 84(5):1651-67.
Yeager, D.S., Purdie-Vaughns, V., Garcia, J., Apfel, N.,
Pebley, P., Master, A., Hessert, W., Williams, M. & Cohen, G.L. (2014).
Breaking the cycle of mistrust: Wise interventions to provide critical feedback
across the racial divide. Journal of Experimental
Psychology: General, 143: 804-824.
Yim H, Dennis SJ, Sloutsky VM. 2013. The development of
episodic memory: items, contexts, and relations. Psychol Sci. 24(11):2163-72.
Image credits for "Aggression in children":
Top image of angry girl by Luis Marina / flickr
Image of mother and child by FennecCooper / flickr
Image of girl and teddy bear / istock
Content of "Aggression in children" last modified 10/2017